I learned about the news because 1/3 of the TRF traffic this morning was directed to articles about Osama bin Laden.
Although many Obama's voters would prefer if this were how Osama should be treated, it wasn't the case. The clear order was to kill him, and once they killed him, they threw him to the sea - to agree with an Islamic counterpart of cremation - no country wanted to host the grave. It wasn't specified whether 72 American virgins were swimming in that sea.
Almost ten years ago, on 9/11/2001 at 9:30 am, I was defending my PhD in New Jersey.
Almost ten years later, the world's most famous terrorist was paradoxically killed by the most pro-Muslim president in the U.S. history. Well, at least he took the credit for the work of the U.S. troops and Pakistani intelligence.
Osama's mansion - seen in this video shot by neighbors - wasn't excessively luxurious. Compare with al-Gore's villa in Santa Barbara.
Well, Obama didn't fail to mention that Osama was not only a Muslim leader but also a "mass murderer of Muslims". Holy cow. I listened to the speech and Obama actually said that Osama was not a Muslim leader. Surely he was. The most influential one. Because of this influence, the freshly and happily dead terrorist has also been the world's most wanted climate jihadist.
Congratulations, America. And rest in hell, Osama.
As people on Twitter say, Obama killing Osama is a sign of a weakly broken supersymmetry in Nature. We have found Osama - and now let's also find the Higgs boson bastard.
The Google Earth or Google Maps coordinates and picture of Osama's mansion are available at other blogs, much like the history of this successful search. What about the consequences? The stock market rally has largely evaporated. Taliban has promised to revenge for the death; meanwhile, Hamid Karzai told his Taliban countrymates that they're ludicrous. And many Muslim bigots don't want to believe that their hero is gone.
Khalid Sheikh Mohammed (CEO of 9/11) has told the U.S. investigators (and to us, via WikiLeaks) that if America hurts his boss, he has a prepared nuclear bomb in Europe that will be destroyed. That's nice and fair! And I am afraid that much of America could say Help yourself. ;-)
Just to be sure, a message for the Islamists: you shouldn't choose the Czech Republic because the defending ice-hockey champion just hammered Denmark, the country of heretics who draw Mohammed, 6-to-0. Four of the goals were scored within three minutes. ;-)
In remotely related news, today, the 20th annual March of the Living - from Auschwitz to Birkenau (a few miles) - is taking place. International Jewish students are brought to learn something about the Holocaust.
IDF soldiers are not missing
Of course, the acronym of March of the Living is MOTL (as in motl.org) - and there used to be times when March of the Living was ahead of your humble correspondent when you were searching for "motl". ;-) After some time, only the Magic Online Trading League could compete a little bit...
Between Fall 1997 and Fall 2001, I lived in a dormitory at the Busch Campus of Rutgers University in Piscataway, New Jersey - in greater New Brunswick.
That's where an act that is effectively a murder took place in September 2010. Chances are nonzero that the key events have occurred in the same apartment where I lived. What happened?
These two folks, Mr Dharun Ravi and Ms Molly Wei, had quite some fun to monitor their gay roommate, music student Tyler Clementi.
On September 19th, Mr Dharun Ravi of Plainsboro streamed the video with a sexual encounter of Mr Clementi with another man, M.B. - using Twitter as a tool to promote the show. Even though a kiss could have been the only thing seen on the "live show", Mr Clementi jumped from the George Washington Bridge to the Hudson River on September 22th - using Facebook to inform his friends and "friends" about his last decision.
Mr Tyler Clementi, the gay victim
The New York Times just reported that Mr Ravi has been indicted by a New Jersey grand jury on hate-crime charges for his usage of the webcam which exposes him to a 5-10 years in prison.
Ms Molly Wei of Princeton who has arguably been as important a part of the "project" as Mr Dharun Ravi will probably escape with no punishment whatsoever. It is pretty obvious from the text that she transferred all her guilt to Mr Dharun Ravi and the jury has bought it. However, her case remains active.
I find Mr Ravi's behavior outrageous. He has probably been a fanatical homophobe. However, the situation has transformed a homophobe to a de facto murderer. Now, it is obvious that people who destroy other people's lives in this way have to be severely punished. The only question is whether the punishment should be distributed among all the bullies, including those whose victims don't commit suicide (or don't get comparably far in their discomfort), or whether only the "unlucky" bullies who effectively kill someone else should be charged with these big charges.
But much more generally: what Mr Tyler Clementi did was totally legal, so any behavior that brings a huge discomfort to such a young man is immoral and should be classified as a crime. Technically, Mr Ravi has "only" violated Mr Clementi's privacy - except that such violations have repercussions, as this sad example clearly demonstrates. These repercussions - the actual ones and maybe even the potential ones - should be included to the juries' decisions.
This was a very sad story. To improve your mood, a new event from the world of "crime" that took place today and that is amusing.
Just as the Hungarian president was beginning his visit to the Prague Castle, two police women from the Republic of Chile arrested Czech President Václav Klaus for his theft of the pen. They announced the decision in Spanish and Czech. However, both cops were rather quickly taken into custody by two Czech cops who happened to be real. ;-)
By the way, Jay Leno has noticed (click) that the main thief during the event was not Prof Klaus but actually his Chilean counterpart who stole... almost everything.
Well, some people can't distinguish reality from parodies. Slovak TV JOJ has informed its viewers that Klaus will begin to medically cure his kleptomania this month. When Ban-Ki-Moon visited Prague, they had to take his credit cards from the pockets because it would be painful if those disappeared. And so on. It turned out that TV JOJ has simply bought a story from a fun portion of an online Czech magazine Reflex - without realizing that it's a hoax! ;-)
Ms Gabrielle Giffords, a Democratic representative in Arizona, was shot into her head. Several others have been killed. She's in critical condition but after the surgery, doctors are optimistic.
The shooter was almost certainly 22-year-old Mr Jared Lee Loughner and the video above tells us something about him.
Well, he had a good taste for music and he could create semi-professional YouTube videos. More importantly, he's been clearly a nutcase.
For example, the video above argues that the years of the Common Era couldn't have begun because they could only come after the years before the Christ. But the latter had to start, too. But because the number minus infinity doesn't belong among the real numbers, it couldn't have started.
(Just to be sure, the mistake is the assumption that subsets of integers have to have a minimum: the set of integers itself doesn't include any minimum.)
He offered similar "arguments" why you can establish a third currency and a third language, among other things. Final slides are directed against the federal U.S. government and against God. But I would obviously not recognize his ideas as some values I find important.
This event is a tragedy. It is more likely that the shooter is a lunatic - a self-described sleepwalker and terrorist - who could have emerged at any time and his act occurred today by a coincidence - rather than as a reaction to some recent events.
Isaac Newton had to verify that his theory of gravity predicted the right elliptical orbits. How did he know they were ellipses? Well, Johannes Kepler determined his laws out of the very accurate data obtained by Tycho Brahe. Both Kepler and Brahe worked in Prague.
A statue of Kepler and Brahe in front of the Kepler High School, near the Prague Castle. Only in Summer 2010, I visited it for the first time.
Tycho Brahe was a Danish nobleman - who has been incorrectly called Tycho de Brahe for centuries - and his death in October 1601 (aged 54+) remains a kind of mystery.
The classic legend says that he was so repelled by the idea of breaking the royal etiquette that he bravely but simply refused to go to the toilet during a long and fancy dinner (where Brahe got drunk a bit) hosted at the Rožmberk Palace of the Prague Castle (that has belonged to Rudolph II for a year, since 1600) by Petr Vok of Rožmberk on October 13th (where Brahe went in a great mood; the guests can only leave the table after the host): his bladder just exploded.
Maybe it didn't but when Brahe returned home, he could no longer use it. More modest sources only speak about a related bladder infection as opposed to an explosion. Others talk about kidney stones which are, according to modern medicine, needed for a bladder to explode (instead of empty itself).
The dinner came just a few days after Brahe's personal meeting with our Emperor Rudolph II who had just hired him to produce new accurate astronomical tables. After escalating pains, he died on October 24th amid tears and prayers by his family. His last words were "Let it be apparent that I didn't live my life in vain." At least Kepler has claimed so. ;-)
However, there are good reasons to think he was poisoned - either by an act of murder or by his own negligence (namely improper experiments with elixirs). In 1901, when his remains were lifted for the last time so far, the researchers found lots of mercury. The Austrian-Hungarian authorities were afraid that the body had been stolen which is why they opened the tomb. Brahe's body was there - but without the metallic nose and without any kidney stones.
In the 1990s, lots of lead were found in Brahe's beard which is probably not unusual given the importance of the element 400 years ago. Also, his dead body may have spent some time in a lead coffin.
The newest hypotheses about the possible murderer are pretty amazing. Brahe had to leave Denmark when Christian IV, a royal bastard, took over at the age of 19 or so. That was different than during the reign of Christian's father, Friedrich II, who employed Brahe as his astrologer and who paid over 5% of the Danish GNP for Brahe's research. ;-)
I called the famous king of Denmark, Christian IV, a bastard not only because he reduced the funding for science but also because he could have actually been Brahe's biological son, as some theories claim! Brahe would create him with Christian's mother Sofie of Mecklenburg-Schwerin at the age of 32 (she was 19+ when Christian was born in 1577).
Some top Danish researchers claim that the young king's mother had an affair with Brahe so either Christian IV or his brother Hans ordered the murder of Brahe; the physical killer would probably be Erik Brahe, Brahe's distant cousin who was a Swedish diplomat (his meeting with Hans in Poland is described in Erik's own diary). In fact, they also say that these stories inspired Shakespeare to write Hamlet which is, you know, a pretty big deal in literature. Recall that Prince Hamlet of Denmark murdered his uncle Claudius.
Of course, when I mention the name Erik, it's also plausible that the murder was realized by some people who have gotten lots of money from the stupid people purely for denying the existence of gravity (2 million euros) which was going to be established because of Brahe's fine work. ;-)
It's 2010 and the right time for another test. Danish toxicologists and other international experts gathered in Prague to do so.
Imagine that you're in Prague, the Czech capital, and you go to the Old Town Square. Instead of looking at the Prague Astronomical Clock (Orloj) on the City Hall that celebrated 600 years just a month ago, you choose the Church of Our Lady (see picture above) that has been called the Týn Church (Týnský Chrám) for many years by the Czech atheists. ;-)
The previous Czech name is literally The Church of Godly Mother in front of Týn (Kostel Matky Boží před Týnem) - Týn Yard is a historical object currently with 18 houses between the Church of Our Lady and Church of Greater St James.
That's where Brahe's remains remained for a long time. It was not clear in what shape the remains would be found today. See the video here or the English one by the BBC to get a glimpse of the atmosphere.
Bladder problems, kidney stones, poisoning by elixirs or murderers remain possibilities. However, there actually exist other possible explanations of the source of trouble. Let me offer you my own.
When Brahe was a student, he fenced against another Nobleman who cut a piece of Brahe's nose. It's a historical fact that the biological material was replaced by a metallic component. The metallic nose wasn't found in 1901 but he has used it for quite some time.
Now, my hypothesis is that the artificial nose was made out of a rather low-quality unstable amalgam with lots of mercucy. (Update: some sources say that the nose was made of gold or a gold-silver alloy.) And in 1601, the material leaked a lot of the heavy liquid metal which would kill Brahe. Dr Vellev has another hypothesis about the source of mercury - a pain reliever that Brahe would take before he died.
I am not sure whether the folks will be able to settle the question, however. The tests will include a CT-scan and an X-ray technique known as PIXE analysis in the Nuclear Research Institute of the Academy of Sciences in Řež, 20 miles from Prague. PIXE analysis was already made in 1996 with some of his hair that were stored in Denmark: they not only found mercury but concluded that it got into his body just a day before his death (i.e. long after the dinner).
Update
At 4:20 pm, it was clear what they roughly found in the grave. They saw two caskets. One belongs to Brahe, another belongs to his wife, a commoner from Kågeröd in Skåne named Kirstin Jörgensdatter who gave Tycho 3 sons and 5 daughters (they never married in a church). His wife's casket is made out of wood and it is in the state of decay. However, there are also astronomers' remains collected in this tightly packed, well-preserved tin coffin.
Click the picture to find 15 more fresh photographs
The Danish folks are not interested in the wife so they plan to leave her in her grave. A piece of a wooden broom was found in the grave, too. A janitor may have left it over there during cleaning exercises in 1901 or earlier.
A sophisticated drilling procedure has to be designed to pick the tin box without damaging the environment too much - because they're also interested about the way how tin coffins used to be put in the grave etc. They're also dreaming about renaissance clothes.
About 100 journalists are present. The research should be speedy because by Friday, all the things should return to the grave. A mass will be held.
Bonus: funeral
Johannes Kepler himself wrote lots of stuff about Brahe's life in Prague and the funeral was no exception. Kepler wrote:
The coffin was carried by twelve imperial officials, mostly noblemen. In long mourning clothes, Tycho's younger son was marching right behind the coffin, in between Erik Brahe [possible murderer] and baron Ernfried von Mincwitz. They were followed by additional imperial aides, barons, and noblemen. Tycho's assistants and servants, Tycho's spouse accompanied by two revered royal judges, and finally his three daughters in separate rows, each of whom was surrounded by two aristocrats. The chairs in the church, on which his family members were sitting, were covered in black English drapery. The streets were so full of people that all those who were walking in the procession were seemingly confined by two walls. And the church was so overcrowded both by the aristocracy as well as low-born people that it was nearly impossible to find a spot for yourself.
Flash: many candidates
This detective flash (in Czech, sorry) may be a little bit too inclusive. Candidate killers include the church as well as Johannes Kepler himself - who may have wanted some unlimited access to Brahe's data. If you walk around, you will also learn about Brahe's life.
Originally posted on 10/01/10, 10:10 am. But I think it should be reposted on 10/10/10, 10:10:10 because the video below became the ultimate symbol of this moment.
Update: the video was labeled "private" on Friday, a minute before 3 p.m., Prague Summer Time, when it had 10,000-20,000 views, 45 positive and 250 negative votes. I managed to download a copy 20 seconds before it disappeared - and then Boom. ;-)
Please contact me if you need a copy. Meanwhile, another YouTube copy uploaded by a skeptic has been embedded below (there exist about 15 skeptics' copies and they want you to perversely vote "thumbs up" to make the video more visible - it's up to you).
You used to believe that you had the right not to believe that it was beneficial to reduce the CO2 emissions. Times are changing.
The 10:10 movement is going to abruptly reduce the CO2 emissions by 10 percent in nine days, on 10/10/10 at 10:10:10 am. How will they do it?
Warning: the following video is brutal: if you don't like gore (and Gore), the movie is not for you
James Lee killed himself too early: he would have surely been delighted by this film. The film was produced by Richard Curtis, a top film director (e.g. many episodes of Mr Bean). He was a hired gun but the people who hired him were for real.
Yes, they will simply kill all people who are openly skeptical: the "No Pressure" video proposes a "final solution" of the problem with the AGW skeptics. No pressure. Just a little bit of pressure that is needed to press a red button and all skeptics in the world will explode in bloodbath. It was their choice - and the alarmist killers will continue smiling. It's excellent, isn't it?
Well, the explosion was the kids' choice in a virtual world. Meanwhile, in the real world, the kids actually have the right to choose without facing such consequences. This basic human right is guaranteed by the constitutions of all civilized countries in the world - and even many uncivilized countries in the world. The people are still allowed to realize - and say - that James Hansen is a nutcase and Al Gore is a greedy liar.
The spiritual fathers of the video at the 10-10 campaign want you to praise them and to send your compliments to hello@1010uk.org. O2 and Sony are among major private sponsors of 10:10. You may thank to howard.stringer@jp.sony.com and pressoffice@o2.com. The film has also been paid from the U.K. taxpayer money.
However, it was the choice of the 10:10 movement to openly promote genocide. They are not just promoting it: much like in the case of The Fate of the World PC game, they are planning it. They are genuinely planning ways how to reduce the global CO2 emissions by 10% a year. And indeed, genocide similar to what they present in the video (or in the game) is the only plausible way how something of the sort may be achieved.
However, if 10:10 has similar ideas what to do with the people from the "other side", they may rename themselves from 10:10 to 9:11; the sum wouldn't change, after all. Al Qaeda U.K. may sound nicer than 9:11.
The CIA, FBI, and others should go after the neck of the inhuman activists behind the 10:10 movement and those who harbor them. These people are a genuine threat not only for your well-being and prosperity but for your freedom and health (or life), too. It is amazing that people such as Gillian Anderson (of X-Files) collaborated to produce this atrocious video. Did someone threaten her with a red button (by the way, would Scully believe that such a thing could work? She must be a true believer: before Y2K, she predicted food shortages because with a wrong date on your PC, people can't load food onto trucks: video), or is she really such a disgraceful bloody N-word b-word?
Unless she was blackmailed, I do think she may want to go to jail.
By the way, the 10:10 campaign probably won't cremate the remains of the 7 murdered individuals because cremation is bad for the climate.
I am not afraid of Pilsen or the Czech Republic: if a climate fearmonger dared to enter our city or our country and he or she would pose a genuine threat for our freedom to breathe or do other activities that produce the gas we call life, he or she would get a proper thrashing - in a more friendly way than on the video, of course.
But I am afraid that the lives of others - not necessarily the white kids on the video above (Philip and Tracy, RIP), but perhaps the lives of black kids in Africa and elsewhere - are genuinely threatened by the now-militant AGW movement that has inherited pretty much all the methods from Nazism, communism, and others. As they have demonstrated, they are surely not repelled by the idea that they will have to kill many people to achieve their insane dreams.
In The Guardian, film director Franny Armstrong (who has already contributed to an aptly named movie called Age of Stupid) claims that their conscience is fine because they have only killed 5 people while 300,000 people are killed by climate change every year. Well, they have actually killed 7 people in the video (murderers of their caliber probably can no longer even count the victims) - and global climate change kills 0 people a year. But is a murder of 5 or 7 people insufficient?
I hope that this mini-movie will make many people realize that climate alarmism is a genuine threat for our freedom, democracy, prosperity, and even security, much like islamic terrorism, and we may have to do something about it. It was actually difficult for me to believe that the movie was created by the actual alarmists. Wasn't it just a movie paid for by some skeptics to exaggerate how a typical alarmist thinks and to blow a final lethal blow to the AGW movement?
Is there any exaggeration in the movie at all? Maybe, the climate alarmists really want to scare the ordinary people to death - make them think that they will be killed if they openly display the skepticism. What will you do, the ordinary people? Are you scared? Well, believe me, children would surely be scared.
An initial caption on the YouTube video argued that there was a "shrinking time frame" for a climate action. Oh, really? (If there were a climate threat of any kind, it would take centuries for it to become substantial.) So maybe if there is such a "shrinking time frame", you may really want to start to kill the people around, right? Franny Armstrong told the Guardian that the detonation could be exaggerated but they could amputate the skeptics' arms and legs. She thinks it's a great and funny idea that should spread in the society.
The explosions of the people may have been computer tricks. But to be sure, the 10:10 campaign has equally passionately destroyed a big airplane, and this act was for real. The airplane was cut into pieces, melted, and transformed into lots of tags with the Nazi-like logo of the eco-terrorist organization.
A self-described "friend" of the inhuman creatures behind the 10:10 movement, who is also harbored by The Guardian, a left-wing U.K. daily, asked his "friends" about the effects and motivations for this shocking piece of work. My understanding is that these unhinged people really want to detonate - or at least scare - millions of humans because they believe that climate action "has" to be done in 4 years (click for a 3-minute video explanation of the deadline). Wow.
The fact that environmentalism originally emerged from Nazism rather than communism has been made clear many times but few of us expected that the true "roots" of environmentalism would ever be made so self-evident, with so many famous people participating.
When you watch the video via YouTube and you click the thumbs-down button, there is another button, "report this video". This video deserves to be reported in all categories - violent content, torturing kids, dangerous work with explosives, and many others. Please, don't invent stories that it's good idea to make these people ever more radical and at large. For the safety of our society, it may be important to have official "stamps" - such as a ban of this video - showing that climate alarmists are not just ludicrous morons but bloody criminals.
(The previous paragraph was written before the video was withdrawn and it is therefore obsolete now.)
I think that many people keep on underestimating how serious those folks are about all these matters. The Guardian knew about the video - and praised it - yesterday. Jamie Glover, a boy who was the first male to explode in the video, was told that he had to be sacrificed to save the world. What did he say afterwards?
Jamie Glover, the child-actor who plays the part of Philip and gets blown up, has similarly few qualms: "I was very happy to get blown up to save the world." The public reaction to the film will be fascinating – please add yours below.
You see that there's no qualitative difference in their methods of brainwashing of the children between the greens and the conventional Islamic jidhadists. They're ready to sacrifice their life for the "highest value". Compare Jamie's answer with the Arabic hit song, "When We Die As Martyrs".
Well, hours after the video had to be removed, I hope that the reactions to the film have been genuinely fascinating for the ecofascists - and they will continue to be fascinating up to the very last 10 minutes and 10 seconds of global warming ecofascism. In this sense, I favor the precautionary principle. Nothing else than a complete liquidation of the climate change ecofascism can safely protect the children's lives at school.
Now, let me just press a little red button here.
Well, I hope you didn't think that I was just like them. ;-)
Sony, Kyocera, and others have terminated their relationships with the 10:10 campaign - and they may represent just the beginning of the recarbonization of the private sector and the return of sensible reasoning to the business world.
However, you may be sure that there still exist people on the fringes of the commercial sector who are faithful to the values of radical alarmism. You are welcome to open a website, Green Chip Stocks dot com, that writes about "a new way of life" and "a new generation of wealth".
He says that the "No Pressure" ad is kind of funny. And it is "bullshit" for someone to say that he is offended. As far as he can say, his opinions show that he has a sense of humor. Well, his text primarily proves that he respects no moral values.
According to Jones, what's really offensive is not that the folks were blown to pieces. What's offensive is that we still "entertain climate change deniers". In other words, the offensive fact (for Mr Jones) is that the movie has not yet been realized in the real world.
Also, we're offered three images that are supposed to be more offensive than the detonation of the indifferent kids and adults:
Click images to zoom in.
These are the three images that Mr Jones finds more offensive than this story:
Wow.
I have spent quite some time looking at the three "offensive" pictures but I still don't get it. What do I see?
The first picture shows a modern city with skyscrapers. There are also some ships or bridges or oil tankers on the river or ocean or whatever it is. The only offensive thing I can see on the picture is the bad weather. Or is it smog? Be sure that ordinary clouds look just like this. Whatever it is, the colors don't look great.
The second picture shows one dead fish near a pond, or whatever it is. The weather was arguably dry. While the demise of the fish may be sad, such a thing has occurred billions of times during the Earth's history so it can hardly be offensive to someone who has an idea about the life on Earth.
The third picture shows a high density of cars on a huge superhighway. I don't even have a hypothesis what can possibly be offensive about this picture - except for the cloudy weather (or smog?). This is what the superhighway was built for. It's good to build highways because they allow cars to get from A to B in shorter time - and, by the way, eliminate pollution from most of the Earth's surface. This particular highway is clearly reaching its capacity which may be an argument to build more highways, rather than fewer highways.
Have I missed something offensive about the pictures? I simply have no clue how someone could compare these totally innocent pictures to the detonation of kids and adults who were just indifferent to mad plans of others to regulate carbon all over the world.
And if Mr Jones says that the three pictures are even more offensive than the sequence of ideologically motivated assassinations, I am simply left speechless.
Moreover, even if you happened to find some - or all - of these three pictures offensive, they have nothing to do with the debates about climate change or with carbon dioxide. People would (hopefully) build skyscrapers and ships even if they eliminated all fossil fuels from their lives.
Also, droughts would sometimes kill some fish, just like they have been doing it for hundreds of millions of years. And lots of cars - possibly electric cars - would still be often clumped on the superhighways because superhighways with a large capacity and high density of cars are simply an efficient way to organize transportation (both from economic and even environmental viewpoint).
So the opinions of Mr Jones just leave me puzzled. There is not a glimpse of an argument that I could recognize as a rational argument. And there is no glimpse of values and priorities that I could expect from someone who may deserve to be called an investor. Are the "new investors" supposed to be offended by every sign of the human economic activity? How is it supposed to work? For all practical purposes, Mr Jones belongs to a different species.
Those organisms may resemble humans but they obviously can't be human in the conventional meaning of the word. They hate humans, their ordinary activitties, and their achievements and they're amused by the murder of the humans. As far as I can say, Mr Jones is just a pollutant in the human society. While Mr Jones likes to obscure this fact, I love carbon dioxide but I dislike genuine pollutants. Sulfur dioxide and Mr Jones are just two examples.
After the fall of communism, we managed to eliminate the former pollutant - almost all of it - from the Czech economy. The same thing holds for many other common pollutants. That doesn't mean that we have removed all things that annoy us or that threaten our health of the economy.
Today in the morning, moments before 9 a.m., a gunman opened fire at the 6th floor of the main library of University of Texas in Austin, the Perry-Castaneda Library (PCL). It's the quietest floor, usually dedicated to people who do some serious research, where you can nicely see their local Capitol.
I have been to Austin once.
The gunman - a white male student with a suit, dark tie, black ski mask, AK-47 (wow), and 6-feet-2 tall - shot around 8-10 times and then he shot himself. Unfortunately, it seems that they have good reasons to be afraid that there exists a second gunman who remains at large. So the police had to lock the university down, cancel the classes for the whole day, and so on. You're told not to visit the campus if you're outside, and if you're in a room, don't open the door to anyone. I hope that this emergency will stop in a safe way for everyone whois at the campus.
Update:There is no #2, police argues now. "Al clear" but lockdown continues.
If you care, it's trivial to find 6-feet-2 tall confused white men in Austin, Texas whose head is drowning in blood and gore, for example Mr Baal of Confusion. :-)
The reason why I observe this story is that the most frequent hostile TRF commenter - who has used about 10 different nicknames - has been connecting from about 10 IP addresses of the University of Texas in Austin. You don't know him - or them - because they were always instantly banned but he is - or they are - very real (or were real?).
This person has clearly been an unhinged madman, with every single comment being an obscenity or a sort of death threat: most of these threats have even religiously defended Mr Smolin and Mr Woit along the way. ;-/ Of course, all the IP addresses were banned from the first moment and I haven't read a vast majority of the comments - that's something that happens when an IP address is banned. Needless to say, I could never answer anything to that person because I had no contacts and any answers in the comment section would mean to approve his comment.
So I am waiting for some signals that it was him - which is not certain (there are 50,000 students at UT Austin!) but which is not quite impossible (there are not too many super-loons among 50,000 people!), as you can imagine. I can't tell you anything about my candidate person except for nicknames - Edward, Albert, Rick, Tim, and others - for the trivialities above and the IP addresses. If the conjecture is right, however, I can give you the subleading predictions for the 5 next places where similar shootings will occur in the future. ;-)
On the other hand, as soon as I "hear" from the candidate who tries to post another comment, the hypothesis will be ruled out.
Update, 10 pm Pilsner time: Too bad, my hypothesis is gone. The jerk, also known as Tibbles, is alive and kicking: 10 junk comments within a few minutes. Just adding another IP address to the black list.
Update, Wednesday: The shooter was a 19-year-old mathematics sophomore, Colton Tooley. Some people have described his being a mathematics sophomore as the motive.
This 35-year-old Gentleman from Somerville, Massachusetts may look like a self-confident practical manager.
However, this Jewish-American holder of a degree in psychology was an intellectual who wrote 1,904 or 1,905 pages of wisdom about freedom, nihilism, transhumanism, sociobiology, God, Judaism, Jewish symbols, Jewish IQ, Anglo-Saxon history, referring to Socrates, Newton, Einstein, Pinker, Dawkins, Mansfield, Dershowitz, and many others, before he shot himself on the top step of Harvard's Memorial Church - in front of dozens of people - on Saturday.
Unfortunately, I doubt that his ultimate sacrifice will earn his opus - which he considered so important - a deserved number of readers although it has already been shown that the number is vastly higher than zero.
But when you compare him with the typical environmental activists and terrorists who recently died in the Discovery Channel or in a family tragedy, and maybe even if you don't compare him to anyone, you must conclude: wow, this guy was a man of wisdom...
Heisman has predicted that his work would be repressed. I am afraid that it will be ignored.
Harvard's Memorial Church, the place where he ended his life; see Google Maps. It's 280 meters from Jefferson Physics Labs where I've worked for 6 years.
Mitchell Heisman when he was found at the staircase: click to zoom in.
See this story in the Harvard Crimson for more pictures and the news that appeared immediately after he pulled the trigger and before the media knew his name.
A special comment for Hong-Kong readers and others: you may want to study this blog in more detail if you're interested in global warming, theoretical physics, elementary particles, string theory, the LHC collider, and other things.
Two days ago, Italy seized $1.9 billion in assets (including 40 companies) - the biggest mob haul ever - in an operation against Mafia's upgrade from the classical drug-running, prostitution, and extortion to their modern replacement, the renewable energy business.
Vito Nicastri (54), known as the Lord of the Wind, was at the center. He's probably linked directly to Matteo Messina Denaro, the likely current boss of the Sicilian Mafia. So the seized assets were probably owned by this "boss of bosses" Denaro.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you a new friend, Vito Nicastri, and a new business, the renewable energy.
The green business has opened such an enormous business with price imbalances and hot air that it would be unthinkable if the existing criminal organizations didn't join the likes of Al Gore in getting the big money in the easiest ways.
James Lee was a typical environmentalist. His opinions were indistinguishable from those of e.g. Alexander Ač and millions of others. Here are his eleven demands from a TV station:
He chose to hate the Discovery Channel because it is arguably one of the last TV stations where positive excitement and love for Nature, science, and technology beats mindless fearmongering. How did Mr Lee want to change the programming schedule of the station?
The Discovery Channel must broadcast programs to fight global warming and help to stop the birth of new humans instead of programs supporting birth (I suppose that his term "parasitic infants" refers to all babies).
The civilization must be presented as the filth it is. The Asian American has also demanded that programs must be developed to stop all immigration to the U.S. The goal of additional programs would be to dismantle the U.S. economy and to promote the Malthusian ideology.
Nothing surprising over there. It's the same rubbish that you have heard hundreds of times from the likes of James Hansen. On his MySpace page, myspace.com/worldguardian (now deleted), James Lee has also stated that it's time for him to "do something about it".
James Lee finally grabbed some weapons and went to hold 3 TV employees of the headquarters of DC in D.C. as hostages. Despite being the guardian of the world, he was dealt with in the obviously sensible way. Good bye, green whacko. The Reference Frame recommends Alexander Ač to avoid the building of Markíza TV in Bratislava today because many of us like you. ;-)
On the other hand, it may be a good idea for the tons of Al Gores of the world to go to their local TV stations and try to hold some hostages.
Thanks to Jaynie B. for the tip.
Bloodhound Gang - The Bad Touch. A savior of the world didn't prevent the Discovery Channel from broadcasting programs about reproduction. So it's time to celebrate although the song may be a little bit filthy. ;-)
As we said, the shooter was 조승희 ... An author of two plays ... (thanks, Rae)
Fingerprints, Korean government, and his own note have confirmed the identity of the Korean shooter
It's horrible news right after my class. At least 32 people plus 1 monster were killed - mostly shot, but some of them chose to jump out of the window - at Virginia Tech University. Dozens of additional people are injured.
The previous shooting at Virginia Tech - last summer - was the work of William Morva: check his background.
The tragedy has become the worst college shooting incident in the history of the world, much worse than a similar incident at University of Texas 40 years ago when "only" 16 people died.
It's so stunning to imagine that a lunatic suddenly enters Jefferson 256 - our physics classroom at Harvard - and shoots everyone in the class.
Learning about the identity
Our preliminary answers on Monday 1:15 pm were 95% correct but the text below was repeatedly updated and it became accurate on Tuesday morning.
Emily Hilscher (18), the girlfriend and the first victim. Click to see her web space. In 2006, she described herself as being "alone".
The killer was a 6-foot tall male East Asian individual staying at a campus. The main suspect, the "most official" boyfriend of the crucial girl, was a student from nearby Radford University (where they just canceled a celebration) but this Gentleman was found alive on Monday, questioned, and released. I believe that it is this man who was dumped by the girlfriend two weeks ago and it is this man who has received his visa in Shanghai before he arrived to San Francisco on August 7th.
On the other hand, the shooter was Seung Hui Cho or Cho Seung Hui if you wish (=Jo Seung Hwee if you hate romanization), a 23 years old South Korean national with a green card (residence: Centerville, VA), and an English major and senior at Virginia Tech. He lived on campus in Harper Residence Hall which are female dormitories (!!!).
Thirty-five days ago, he purchased two guns - one 9 mm caliber handgun (namely Glock 19) and one .22 caliber pistol (namely Walther P-22) - and he wore jeans, a vest or a black leather jacket - probably a bulletproof vest - with too much ammunition in it as well as a maroon cap. Tape showing how he is buying the guns exists: to make this story a bit fine-tuned, these tapes are stored exactly for thirty-five days.
Ryan Clark, the 2nd victim. Click to see his web space.
In the morning around 7:15 am, Mr. Cho went to her dormitory at the fourth floor of the West Ambler Johnston Hall. He shot "his" girlfriend and then the residential assistant, Ryan Clark of Martinez, Georgia who was bi- and who may have dated Hilscher. They thought it was a localized "home shooting" so they didn't shut down the university. Mr. Cho has thus rearmed and continued to look for a new boyfriend of "his" girlfriend or other unlucky people in the engineering classrooms of the Norris Hall - see the picture above - a few hours later.
He didn't know the exact location, so he has visited a few classrooms and lined up all students against a wall. Around 9:20 am, he started with Norris 206 (probably a French course) and continued with Solid Mechanics 3154 in Norris 204. The instructor, a former NASA employee Liviu Librescu, tried to save the kids by blocking the door. But he was shot. One of the heroes of the day.
However, the worst massacre took place at 9:45 am in room 200 where the students were learning German 2105. He shot them one by one; yes, the professor, Jamie Bishop who was a son of science-fiction writer Michael Bishop, died first. My most profound condolences for his family, Jason Erik Lundberg, and other friends...
Finally, the calm animal who revealed no emotions whatsoever killed himself by a shot into his head once he was cornered.
The Asian guy above is just a photographer for a VT student newspaper, Shaozhuo Cui or Shao. The shooter looked different when the police got him: for example, a part of his face was already missing.
Chamail Chalaf was a journalist with Radio Free Europe / Radio Free Iraq, an American radio station with headquarters in Prague - since 1995 when it was moved from Munich.
She was dreaming about the best possible future for Iraq. The mother of three daughters was kidnapped on Tuesday and her body was found on Thursday: she was shot in her head. Almost 100 journalists were killed since 2003; about 20% of them were non-Iraqis.
She seems to be the kind of journalists whom I respect. Sadly, she is no longer around. Unfortunately, these people have much lower life expectancy than the global warming journalists: this sentence is exactly equivalent to the previous one.
Terror speech codes: EU goes 1984
Meanwhile, the European Union has approved a new secret lexicon - a speech code how all the official spokespeople of the member countries should talk about the Islamic terrorists.
For example, the term "Islamic terrorism" should be banned and replaced by something like "terrorism that justifies its acts by Islam above a tolerable level". I kid you not. :-) Also, the word "jihad" should disappear because it is considered to be a "spiritual struggle" by "most" Muslims.
I think it is kind of crazy that the officials in Brussels think that they can create secret lexicons and all public representatives in the whole continent will respect it. My optimistic guess is that e.g. no Czech politician will follow such an inherently non-democratic restriction. More drastically, I feel that it would be a treason if a Czech politician were controlled by secret agreements signed in Brussels, and according to the valid laws, he or she could be prosecuted.
For example, the prime minister Mr Mirek Topolánek prefers this gesture. ;-)
Provocative comments about Romanies
The deputy prime minister, Mr Jiří Čunek, the current leader of the Christian Democratic Union, has answered a question whether other people should receive the same subsidies as gypsies. He said that "they would have to get a suntan, mess up their families, put up fires on the town squares, and only then some politicians would think that they are really miserable people."
This comment, while based on some reality, is a painfully xenophobic and populist one: the second adjective is true because he expressed sentiments shared by 90% of Czechs or so. This guy continues to be supported by his Christian Democratic Union and the prime minister prefers to keep him in the government. Greens disagree.
President Klaus has criticized the words as unacceptable populism that builds on the prejudices of no small part of the Czech public.
I personally find it dangerous if emotions against a group of people - any group of people - are supported by oversimplified arguments. Also, fanning hatred is a crime in Czechia - and some gypsies' NGOs are already suing the deputy PM. The gypsies' life is not easy: for example, about 20 percent of them have regular jobs. I think that it is mostly about them but it is not purely about them and no member of the "majority" society should be overly happy about the status quo. Also, I feel that the subsidies may be cheaper than the harm that the society would face if these subsidies didn't exist. Subsidies are usually wrong but if they're justifiable in some case, the example of gypsies is the best example.
On the other hand, Mr. Čunek argues that one of his goals in the government is to establish conditions in which many gypsies will start to work. If he could do it without leading hundreds to death by starvation, it would of course have to be applauded. But it's just not easy and no politician should create the impression that various things like that are easy.
As Rae Ann has pointed out, exactly 2050 years ago, Julius Caesar was killed. It happened on Ides of March, i.e. on March the 15th, 44 BC. Note that 2007+44=2051 but you must subtract one because there was no year "zero" in our calendar.
Caesar's last words were "Et tu, Brute?" - "Even you, Brutus?". Well, it wasn't actually the case but because The Reference Frame respects the inventor of this legend, William Shakespeare, we will pretend that we believe that it is true. ;-)
He is a post-modern writer who also melancholically describes a clash of cultures. What may be even more interesting is that in February 2005, he stated in an interview that 1 million Armenians and 30,000 Kurds were killed by Turkey in 1915-17 and he was the only one to dare to talk about it.
Because he was right on both counts, he immediately became a target of a hateful campaign by the Turkish nationalists and had to flee the country. In June 2005, the Parliament introduced a new law that made it a crime to say anything bad about Turkey and Pamuk was retroactively charged with "insulting Turkishness". Wow.
What's interesting is that almost exactly at the very same moment when Pamuk's Nobel prize was announced, the National Assembly of France voted 106-19 for a new bill that makes it illegal, on the contrary, to deny the Armenian Genocide. Normally I support Turkey's membership in the EU but we often have to face various questions: is it a good starting point for harmony if it is crime in one member country not to admit a certain thing that is a crime to say in another country?
Ms. Ana Elisa Toledo (24) from Sao Paolo has been fed up with her boyfriend, Mr. Martin Novotný (23) from Česká Lípa, a Czech town, for several months - especially because he often turned violent in their relationship. Both of them had worked as au-pair in Denver. She has eventually decided to move on. He couldn't stand a picture of her hugging another man on her website.
On December 13th, 2005, he came to the house of the family where Ana worked through the window. When she woke up, he "blacked out" and hurt her repeatedly with his knife. She was screaming so he placed a pillow over her face and used his knife again. I didn't want to tell you but he stabbed her 74 times; the experts say that you only need half a minute if you get mad. He returned home to have a shower and to throw away the dirty clothes and knife. The same day, he decided that he can't escape from this trouble, so he called police and confessed to the murder.
What a frustrating story. He will probably avoid the death penalty and get a life in prison - the same verdict as for another Czech who killed his female countrymate in Sweden in 2004, and another Czech who killed a 17-year-old student in Germany. All these killers are in their mid 20s. The only exception was Václav Plch who got life in prison for a brutal murder of a black mother of five back in 2000: he was 39.
Both Martin and Ana were intelligent, peaceful, but also extremely jealous and passionate. Ana has even visited Martin's parents in Česká Lípa and they had no doubts that she would never live with someone else than their son: unfortunately, they were probably right. My deep condolences to the Brazilian family.
Mark Trodden at Cosmic Variance celebrates that the BBC conjectured that the terrorists and their buddies at Guantanamo Bay will enjoy increased luxury in their lives. As you can imagine, your humble correspondent celebrates very different things, and in some sense the very opposite things than Mark Trodden does.
Ladies and Gentlemen, most of you have probably heard that Shamil Basayev is dead. The Russian president correctly says that death is not enough for such a monster. Well, Basayev is responsible for hundreds of deaths - 300+ people in the school at Beslan, the Moscow theater siege etc. - which are thousands of times more valuable than his life.
There are other reasons to be happy that this Islamic terrorist has joined his buddy al-Zarqawi. Basayev thought that Osama bin Laden had to be a great person because his face always emits light on all photographs. Moreover, Basayev was obsessed with the very same human garbage as some of our liberal friends - namely with the communist terrorist Che Guevara. ;-)
We may be cautious about Russia in many subtle cases and we can also sympathize with many nations whose independence was suppressed by the Russian bear, but in this particular case, all good people should admit that the Chechen Islamic terrorism affecting Russia is completely analogous to the Islamic fundamentalist terrorism directed against America and other Western countries. Basayev's death is not a sufficient punishment but it is still a good news.
I wonder whether the explosion was a result of a good work of the Russian intelligence forces or whether it was a genuine accident. It is likely that we won't ever learn the answer, and if we learn it, it will not necessarily be the correct answer because of the intense propaganda war in the background.
Death is rarely a reason to celebrate, but the death of Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, the prince of Al-Qaeda for the territory of Mesopotamia in between two rivers and one of the most disgusting and annoying killers in the world, is definitely one of the exceptional cases. Congratulations to all who participated in this good work.
It was not that difficult after all - as easy as this game. Once they learned about his coordinates, they have sent him a 500-pound gift - navigated by Light Amplified by Stimulated Emission of Radiation, also known as LASER - and then another piece of justice of the same rest mass - even though the rest frame was not too useful to describe the scenery after the gift landed. The local Iraqi police could have found him, together with five of his appendices. The identification was 100% successful and celebrations could start.
Not everyone celebrates. The father of Nicholas Berg - who was beheaded by al-Zarqawi himself (and many of us have seen the disgusting video) - probably did not like his son too much. He prefers a dumb pacifict ideology according to which the death of al-Zarqawi is a "doubly bad news". No doubt, the prepaid journey of al-Zarqawi to the hell (that Al-Qaeda calls the paradise even though it is full of dirty killers from their own institution) does not mean that Iraq will become a heaven. But I think it is a severe blow to the terrorist organization - and to all of its sympathizers, for that matter: some of them may be just reading this paragraph. ;-)
Some Arabs say that the insurgency will continue but their comments are internally inconsistent. Some of them say that a more radical leader will take over, some of them say that less radical insurgents will become more effective. I think that many of the thugs will finally realize that they can't win their battle and they are not welcome in this world, at least not in the alive form, as long as their acts resemble the acts of their former leader, even remotely.
Meanwhile, Osama bin Laden should notice how happy everyone is, and he should finally reveal his coordinates, too. ;-) When I say "everyone", it includes Al-Qaeda itself that announced the good news on their website as follows:
"We want to give you the joyous news of the martyrdom of the mujahed shaikh Abu Musab al-Zarqawi."
This is what I call a win-win situation. ;-)
Bolton vs. U.N. bureaucrats
In another story, an intense verbal exchange between the U.S. and the U.N. took place. An aide of Kofi Annan suggested, in a coded diplomatic language, that the U.S. should punish ("stand up to") domestic critics of the U.N. such as Rush Limbaugh and Fox News. John Bolton, the U.S. ambassador to the U.N., realized that this proposed Mugabe-like global "democracy" is a bit over the edge. So he identified the speech of the U.N. bureaucrat to be a "very, very grave mistake" and requested that Kofi Annan will denounce that speech: otherwise the existence of the U.N. itself is at stake. So far, Annan has failed to do so.
I also find it unacceptable that people from an international bureaucratic body that was not elected by anyone - certainly not by me - should have the power to silence their critics, especially if the critics are right.
December 19, 2007 update: Grandparents' appeal rejected, a jury (10 women + men) discusses voluntary manslaughter again, her state of mind is becoming the key.
September 12th, 2007 update: Mary Winkler may get her kids back
June 8th, 2007 update: Mary Winkler asks for mercy and indeed, she will only serve 210 days in prison although she was sentenced for 3 years. The message: if your husband annoys you, just shoot him.
April 19th, 2007 update: Jury decides it was voluntary manslaughter (definition), 3-6 years. Mary Winkler showed no emotions when she was convicted.
April 18th, 2007 update: Mary Winkler doesn't really remember picking the gun. He criticized her hair and wanted her to watch porn and have "unnatural" sex afterwards, and kicked her into face, and she just wanted him not to be mean. She didn't pull the trigger but something suddenly went off - boom - and he was dead. Guns sometimes have "unnatural" spontaneous ejaculations, it seems.
April 14th, 2007 update: Experts say that the gun was working well. Mary Winkler was deeply in trouble with the Nigerian scam.
April 12th, 2007 update: Mary Winkler claims that she was abused and the death was an accident - she just wanted attention from Matthew. On Friday 13th, she admitted shooting, claiming it was done by her ugly.
April 9th, 2007 update:Jury selection started. Dan and Diane Winkler filed a \$2 million lawsuit against Mary Winkler, apparently to prevent her from profiteering via book or movie deals.
November 2006 update: Mary Winkler argues that the murder was due to constant abuse.
Final news: Mary Winkler told police that she shot Matthew Winkler after a fight. She was fed up with her husband telling her how to eat, how to walk, etc. Especially, there was an argument about family finances that she managed. She deposited \$17,500 into family accounts because she apparently became a victim of scams - Canada and even Nigeria (a famous source of a certain kind of scam) appeared in the testimony. See a reconstruction. Bond was set to \$750,000: she will have to kill about minus 30 more husbands to be able to use it. Surprisingly, she did it.
The following entries are sorted anti-chronologically, and the main, original part of this article is at the bottom. I think that the resolution does not confirm all the details I predicted. It confirm, of course, the primary statement that in non-priest families, this would probably get solved by a divorce.
News: Mary Winkler might have been indicted on Monday 6/12 - indeed, she was indicted - and as predicted, she appeared in court on Wednesday 6/14, pleaded "not guilty" and asked for a bond. The children are happy with the grandparents. Around 6/19, Winkler's attorney has filed 25 motions (everything about this case is unusual), especially trying to hide Winkler's testimony for the police and the evidence from the court because it was obtained "illegally". Meanwhile, some people start to speculate about the death penalty.
Update: Mary Winkler celebrates Mother's Day in prison.
Disclaimer: chances are that you got here because of a search engine. This page does not contain the ultimate answer - although the Tennessee officials already know it and it is something very particular - but you may still learn something. Please don't be evil when you speculate about the motives.
Last Thursday, Mary Winkler who is held without bail was expected to plead not guilty and explain her motive but she has waived the public hearing to simplify the life of her daughters. It is conceivable that Steve Farese - who told us to "expect the unexpected" last Thursday even though nothing happened after all - has advised Winkler to shelve the original explanation and they will eventually claim that the murder occured because of post-birth depression.
The family's computers have been seized to find the answer that 2,000 people a day try to find on this page. And the attorney will even attempt to show that the shooting was an accident! In a newer development on Wednesday 04/05, the attorney has encouraged the speculations about Matthew Winkler's pedophilia when he said that "She may have been protecting someone".
Figure 1: Mary Winkler and defense attorney Steve Farese in Selmer court (AP Photo/Rogelio Solis). Can she get a fair trial?
The Winkler family is described by their neighbors as a perfect family: a precious mother and wife (and a teacher), a superb and charismatic father and husband (and a preacher), and loving, bright, happy children. In fact, it is completely useless to ask neighbors about these issues because unless the motives are obvious, the neighbors will always tell you the same thing, namely that the murderer and her family were perfect. It must be so. It is a physical law.
Why is it a physical law? It is because a murder is an extreme, infrequent act, and it must therefore have extreme reasons. Extreme reasons for a murder fall into two extreme categories: either the murderer and the victim have been involved in some extremely obvious controversial events such as sexual abuse or organized crime, or they have been hiding and suppressing some of their feelings in an extremely tight mental box.
The Church is, much like the Academia, an ideal place that encourages hypocricy - and that often prefers the form over the content. This is why this Hungarian pastor has been less popular than Matthew Winkler. In fact, the Church of Christ also likes to oppress women as the Median Sibling convincingly argues.
Figure 2: Matthew Winkler, a minister
Although many bloggers are ready to invent far-reaching theories about Matthew Winkler, I continue to assume that he was primarily a victim of a murder, and I find it highly inappropriate to accuse victims themselves of crimes without having a good reason. Of course, some people disagree with me and the radical feminists consider Mary Winkler to be their hero. Every husband should hire a personal injury solicitor or a bodyguard.
What was her motive?
That's a question that many people are obviously asking these days. It turns out that the Tennessee officials already know the answer but they can't yet disclose it. Of course, I don't know the answer but one can still speculate. There can be something very concrete behind the murder. For example, Matthew Winkler could have been involved in pedophilia - as Jennifer and many other women believe - or something effectively equivalent that his wife really hated. I find such an explanation rather unlikely. Instead, let me say a few general comments.
I have been exposed to the very same fundamentalist Christian environment for a year or so - because of my former girlfriend - and this experience has brought me, among other things, some striking insights. First of all, those Christians who believe the Bible literally - and the Winklers clearly fall into this category - find certain acts, including pre-marriage sex and divorce, unimaginable. Under these extreme circumstances, a murder can become easier than a divorce.
If you press CTRL/F and search for bcos on this page, you will find a theory that Mary's "bi-polar" psychological problems are behind the murder. The only problem with this theory is that "bi-polar" psychological problems are probably not what could be called "a particular motive" which is what the officials say led to the murder. But it's certainly true that the amount of expectations from pastors' wives and their loneliness is immense.
One thing seems clear to me right now: Mary Winkler did not love her husband in the usual, emotional sense. If she did, she could not have killed him. This fact could have had very ordinary biological reasons. According to the photographs, I wouldn't personally consider them to be a match because the physiques of the partners should be comparable.
Update (4/29/2006): In March, I was apparently the only blogger in the world who has pointed out the different physical size as a factor to consider. At the end of April, Farese (the attorney) was mysteriously referring to the culture of "men being physically bigger than women" as a key point of the defense.
The reason behind their marriage could have been something very different from internal love, and I suspect it is the case in many Christian families. You can also speculate about the importance of the miscarriage that Mary Winkler had before their youngest baby was born.
You can also imagine that her husband wanted her to have a fourth child - by mathematical induction, the fourth daughter - but she disagreed but was not in charge of this decision.
Mary Winkler could have found someone else, too. But a divorce is unthinkable for a charismatic, fundamentalist preacher as you know. Such a thing would destroy his career and not only his career. According to the sixth commandment, a murder is unthinkable, too. But unlike the divorce, she at least did not need any permission from her husband.
Did she believe that no one would figure out that she has killed her husband? If she did, she must be a really stupid woman. Many people in Tennessee say that she was very nice. I don't like the word "nice" too much. If you statistically evaluate what the word is used for, it has a large amount of compassion in it. Moreover, the word "nice" also represents a quiet compliance with the values of the environment as well as some degree of confusion about what the person really thinks. If you think for a while, it is not exactly a compliment for someone to be called "nice".
At any rate, Matthew Winkler is gone and in a couple of hours or days, we will learn what is the official explanation of the murder. It seems that the daughters have not yet learned what happened to their father. I guess they can survive it pretty well. A new minister in Tennessee will be hired. They will show him his new parsonage: this is where the guy before you was killed by his "loving" wife. Good luck to everyone!
Rae Ann shares many things with Mary Winkler, yet she is so different. Some lyrics refreshes her meditation about this event. Or do you want to know what Mary Winkler would write if she had a blog? If you're looking for an even more extensive discussion than the discussion in the two comment sections under this article, see the Huff Crime Blog