Showing posts with label Wiki. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Wiki. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Using Wikipedia and Google for medical information

Some interesting abstracts from PubMed:

"Google is an efficient web resource for identifying specific medical information." Google was more efficient than all other resources for identifying medical information (P less than 0.0001) http://bit.ly/6FXATW

Google Scholar versus PubMed in locating primary literature to answer drug-related questions: no major differences http://bit.ly/8OygYt

Wikipedia is not authoritative and should only be a "supplemental source" of drug information http://bit.ly/7qzZ7k

Does Wikipedia provide evidence-based health care information? http://bit.ly/4WVLHt - No. Who is surprised?

Personality characteristics of Wikipedia members: Introverted women more likely to be members than extroverted women http://bit.ly/8YfrXb

Mobile Websites from Pubmed: Search Abstracts and Find Disease Associations http://bit.ly/7ucyn5 - Works on Kindle too. The mobile MedlinePlus (for consumers) is at m.medlineplus.gov http://bit.ly/6jjkt3


Image source: Doctors Using Google by Philipp Lenssen, used with permission.

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Doctors add expert insights and comments about websites in Google Sidewiki

From Google:

"As you browse the web, it's easy to forget how many people visit the same pages and look for the same information. What if everyone, from a local expert to a renowned doctor, had an easy way of sharing their insights with you about any page on the web? What if you could add your own insights for others who are passing through?

Google Sidewiki allows you to contribute helpful information next to any webpage. Google Sidewiki appears as a browser sidebar, where you can read and write entries along the side of the page."



Here are two examples how doctors add expert insights and comments about websites in Google Sidewiki:

- Michael Roizen http://bit.ly/132azY

-
Steven Nissen http://bit.ly/10HWLk

Both are prominent physicians at the world-renowned Cleveland Clinic.

A few comments on this new Google service are posted below:

Google Steps Where Many Have Stumbled: Sidewiki http://bit.ly/2fxwqC

@Scobleizer: "Google Sidewiki is latest attempt by big company to make money off of my content on my blog. I really hate companies that let people put stuff on top of my content without my consent."

Google Launches Sidewiki — More Like a Universal Commenting System http://bit.ly/nMwvN

Related:
How to Claim Your Website’s Google Sidewiki http://bit.ly/6m89E

Updated: 10/04/2009

Tuesday, September 15, 2009

Wikipedia Is Not a Reliable Source of "Actionable" Medical Information

@Laikas, a Dutch medical librarian, took the time to write a long and thoughtful blog post, well-suited for submission to a journal as an editorial:

The Trouble with Wikipedia as a Source for Medical Information http://bit.ly/m42zO

She quoted an example which showed that some doctors apparently rely on Wikipedia to the extent they refer to it in medical journal publications - see this Int. J Cardiol. PubMed abstract: http://bit.ly/9wCMO

Lee CH, Teo C, Low AF. Fulminant dengue myocarditis masquerading as acute myocardial infarction. Int J Cardiol. 2009 Aug 21;136(3):e69-71. Epub 2008 Aug 13.

The Heart Institute, National University Hospital Singapore, Singapore. Leechihang@nuh.com.sg

Dengue fever is manifested by a sudden onset of fever (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fever), with severe headache, myalgias (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myalgia), arthralgias (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthralgia) and characteristic bright red petechia (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petechia). The exact incidence and pathophysiological mechanism of dengue myocarditis remain obscure, but most of these cases are self-limiting. Fatal dengue myocarditis is a very rare complication of dengue fever. The non-specific symptoms and signs of dengue myocarditis make early diagnosis difficult. A 25-year-old Indian male, suffered from fulminant dengue myocarditis, presented to a our hospital with symptoms and electrocardiographic features mimicking acute myocardial infarction. Unfortunately, the patient succumbed before the dengue serology results were available.

In my opinion, Wikipedia is almost impossible to rely on for medical searches - unless you know the material and just use the text/images for illustrative purposes. One of the many differences between a blog and a medical journal is that, for example, I often reference Wikipedia on the blog, but never in a journal.

@FoodAllergyMD
asked on Twitter: "
If we have come to citing open source, anyone-can-post/edit media, should I be looking for other signs of the apocalypse?"

@Giustini, a Canadian medical librarian, mentioned the well-publicized opinion that "there is nothing wrong starting [a medical search] with Wikipedia but it should never be the last place to search." Humorously, I asked if we should start our medical searches with NYT or WSJ then...

There is even a discussion on FriendFeed which can be summarized as "Is it OK to use Wikipedia citations in Int J Cardiology?" http://bit.ly/14rBuW

I have commented on this topic multiple times in the past (please see the links at the end of this post). In short, medical blogs are not a source of "actionable" medical information. The same principle applies to Wikipedia. You must be treated by an expert - not a "crowd" - as in the "wisdom of crowds" concept used by Wikipedia.

Twitter comments:

@chrisseper: "One way to lose confidence in a doc. Ask a medical question and see the doc go online & find the answer via Wikipedia."

@palmdoc: "Would anyone lose confidence in a Doc who looks up Google? I'd be worried if they don't know how to Google."

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Wikipedia used by 70% of junior physicians, dominates search results for health queries

Study: Junior physician's use of Web 2.0 for information seeking and medical education:

Google and Wikipedia used by 80% and 70% of physicians, respectively http://is.gd/1oQky

Wikipedia is a prominent source of online health information compared to the other online health info providers studied. Wikipedia ranked among first ten results in 71–85% of search engines and medical keywords tested. In search tests, "Wikipedia surpassed MedlinePlus and NHS Direct Online and ranked higher with quality articles" http://bit.ly/39Xq8k

I didn't understand why @Berci spent so much time editing medical articles in Wikipedia. Now I know and it has obviously made an impact.

Also, I have dismissed Wikipedia as a medical resource until so many residents reported using it during the NEJM Horizons conference in October 2008.

Observation: Just look around you in computer section of medical library of any university & see how many students check Wikipedia. Whether we like or not (and I haven't for a long time), medical students use Wikipedia (a lot) http://bit.ly/39Xq8k

Do you think any medical encyclopedia (@medpedia, AskDrWiki) has any sustainable future facing Wikipedia headstart?

Twitter opinions:

@chrisseper: "One way to lose confidence in a doc. Ask a medical question and see the doc go online & find the answer via Wikipedia."

@palmdoc: "Would anyone lose confidence in a Doc who looks up Google? I'd be worried if they don't know how to Google."

Related:
Web 2.0 for Emergency Physicians http://bit.ly/uFnA0 - A must read. Applies to all physicians. Recommended.
The Trouble with Wikipedia as a Source for Medical Information. Laika’s MedLibLog.
Wikipedia: A Key Tool for Global Public Health Promotion (review article)
Image source: Doctors Using Google by Philipp Lenssen, used with permission.